November 19, 2026
The City of Prince Albert's own assessment model values a Carlton Park location at almost exactly the same level as Crescent Acres. Carlton Park houses are still estimated well below Crescent Acres houses. The difference comes from the houses themselves. The report's median effective year built is 1979 for Carlton Park's R1 homes and 1995 for Crescent Acres. Going the other way, Carlton Park costs more than East Hill and Crescent Heights mainly because of the address. For a buyer, that means Carlton Park money goes first to the location and then to a house with a typical effective age in its mid-forties.
This post works through that split using numbers you can check: the City's assessment model and the most recent October 2026 neighbourhood estimates.
HonestDoor's mid-October 2026 model puts the average Carlton Park house at $342,222. The same October reports put Crescent Heights at $275,178, East Hill at $259,203 and Crescent Acres at $434,770.
So in October 2026, an average Carlton Park house was about $67,000 above Crescent Heights, about $83,000 above East Hill and about $92,500 below Crescent Acres. These are model estimates, not closed sale prices. Carlton Park's house average stayed between about $342,000 and $351,000 in each monthly report from June through October 2026.
Those dollar gaps can come from two things: the location, or the house sitting on it. The City's model separates the two.
The City of Prince Albert's 2025 Revaluation Residential Assessment Model covers the appraisal cycle from January 1, 2025 through December 31, 2028, so it's the model in effect today. It's built from sales. The assessor compares properties with similar homes that have sold, and uses multiple regression to measure how features like age, size, quality and location each affect price.
One of those measurements is a neighbourhood factor. The report describes it as reflecting "how the sale market behaves differently between the residential neighbourhoods in Prince Albert." If two houses are otherwise the same, the factor shows how their value changes from one neighbourhood to another.
| Neighbourhood | Neighbourhood factor |
|---|---|
| Adanac Pointe | 1.097 |
| Lakeview | 1.097 |
| River Street East | 1.009 |
| Carlton Park | 1.003 |
| Crescent Acres | 1.000 |
| West Hill, Market Area 1 | 0.986 |
| River Heights | 0.934 |
| Southwood | 0.931 |
| Crescent Heights, Market Area 1 | 0.922 |
| East Hill, Market Areas 1 and 2 | 0.845 |
| Crescent Heights, Market Area 2 | 0.782 |
Carlton Park comes in at 1.003 and Crescent Acres at 1.000. Those numbers are close enough to treat as equal. By the City's measure, a house in Carlton Park and an otherwise identical house in Crescent Acres are worth about the same. Among standard city neighbourhoods, Carlton Park is in the top tier, below only Adanac Pointe, Lakeview and River Street East. The acreage category also ranks higher.
Crescent Acres' higher price comes from the age of its housing stock. The same report gives a median effective year built for each neighbourhood. For Carlton Park's R1 homes, the median is 1979, within a range of 1959 to 1999. For Crescent Acres it's 1995, within a range of 1976 to 2024.
The model's depreciation table shows how much age lowers value. Effective age is counted from January 1, 2023. A home 20 to 29 years old gets a factor of 0.807, and a home 40 to 49 years old gets 0.654. On that base date, a home at the Crescent Acres median had an effective age of 28 years and one at the Carlton Park median had an effective age of 44. Divide 0.807 by 0.654 and the newer house comes out about 23% ahead on age alone.
Now compare that with the October model averages. In October 2026, the Crescent Acres average was about 27% above Carlton Park's. Age accounts for most of that gap. The location accounts for almost none of it.
This matters for the Crescent Acres question many families are weighing. If you choose Carlton Park over Crescent Acres, you aren't trading down on location. At the medians, you're buying a home with an effective year built about 16 years earlier, at about the same location value.
The depreciation table also explains the gap in the other direction. After about 40 years, the age factor barely changes. It's 0.654 for 40 to 49 years, 0.653 for 50 to 59 and 0.641 for 60 to 69.
The median effective year built is 1969 for Crescent Heights Market Area 1 and 1957 for East Hill Market Area 1. At their medians, all three neighbourhoods sit on the flat part of that curve. A home with a 1979 effective year built and one with a 1969 effective year built get almost the same age factor.
So the price gap comes mainly from the address. Using the neighbourhood factors, the same house is worth about 9% more in Carlton Park than in Crescent Heights Market Area 1, and about 19% more than in East Hill. The October 2026 gaps were wider, about 24% over Crescent Heights and 32% over East Hill. The rest likely comes from other things the model measures, such as size and quality. The location premium is still the biggest single piece.
It's easy to credit Carlton Park's prices to what's been built on its southeast edge. The Lake Country Co-op Leisure Centre opened to the public on September 5, 2025, after construction from July 2022 to February 2025. The City describes it as part of The Yard, an 80-acre private development. Council approved the land purchases in 2020 and 2021.
The assessment model uses an effective valuation date of January 1, 2023. That's more than two and a half years before the Leisure Centre opened its doors. The location value of 1.003 comes from sales before the building opened. The model was already pricing the neighbourhood's long-standing anchors, all named in the report: Carlton Comprehensive, the Art Hauser Centre, Prime Ministers' Park and the Carlton Park Community Club. The newer amenities, covered in what changed on Carlton Park's doorstep, came on top of an address that was already valued like Crescent Acres.
The City's model defines Carlton Park as the area between Marquis Road, 6th Avenue East, 28th Street East and 15th Avenue East. Two recent listings inside it match the pattern above.
A house on Dunn Drive was listed on November 12, 2026 at $298,000. It's a 1,068-square-foot home built in 1979, with three bedrooms on the main floor, four bedrooms and two bathrooms in total, a developed basement and a large backyard with a deck and firepit. Its build year matches Carlton Park's median effective year built, and its asking price is below the neighbourhood's October model average.
A house on 15th Avenue East was listed in September 2026 at $369,900. It has 1,143 square feet, was built in 1988, and has four bedrooms, three bathrooms, a detached 24-by-26-foot garage and a partly fenced yard. The two homes differ by about 75 square feet and $71,900. The house on 15th Avenue East is nine years newer and has the garage and the extra bathroom. Since both sit at the same location value, most of that price difference comes from the house.
According to the Saskatchewan REALTORS® Association's September 2026 monthly report, Prince Albert's benchmark price was $280,000, up 1.2% from September 2025. For the Prince Albert Region that month, the report showed 179 sales, 5.02 months of supply and an average price of $304,204. Sales were down 19% and months of supply up 12% from a year earlier. Buyers had more time and more choice than they did last fall.
The SRA's October 2026 release reported 1,262 sales across the province and a provincial benchmark of $373,300 in October. It also said Prince Albert continues to see significant year-over-year price growth. Carlton Park's October model average of $342,222 sits well above the city benchmark, which fits a neighbourhood in the city's top location tier.
With more supply than last year, a Carlton Park buyer can take time to compare houses within the neighbourhood. Location value is about the same across Carlton Park, so the house is where homes really differ.
Is Carlton Park priced like a newer neighbourhood? By location value, yes. The City's 2025 model rates Carlton Park at 1.003 and Crescent Acres at 1.000. The typical Carlton Park house is older, though, with a median effective year built of 1979.
Did The Yard push Carlton Park prices up? The model's location value comes from sales up to January 1, 2023, before the Lake Country Co-op Leisure Centre opened in September 2025. The premium was already in place before the building opened.
What was an average Carlton Park house worth this fall? HonestDoor's mid-October 2026 model estimate was $342,222. That's a modelled average, not a closed sale price, and individual listings this fall have ranged above and below it.
If you're comparing a Carlton Park house with one in Crescent Acres or East Hill and want to know how much of each price is the address and how much is the house, Brooke Wozniak is happy to talk it through with you. Book a consultation, and we'll look at where your money goes in each home before you write an offer.
Stay up to date on the latest real estate trends.
Whether you’re searching for your dream home or selling a property, Brooke’s insight, negotiation skills, and dedication ensure a seamless experience.